
Date posted: January 25, 2008
Monitor Audio Gold GS-LCR Monitor Audio Gold GS-FX Surround Monitor Audio Silver RSW-12 Subwoofer Distributor: Kevro International Inc., Once known best for its cabinetry, Monitor Audio has come quite a distance in recent years to become notable for the audio quality and manufacturing consistency of its loudspeakers of all sorts, without losing that leading edge in furniture fashioning. The beefing up of their engineering in recent years has resulted in some speakers that both look and measure very well. Perhaps not entirely modestly, the company describes its GS20 floorstanding speaker as, “combining gorgeous aesthetics, sublime sonics and superlative build quality. Its two-and-a-half way, three driver configuration is built around dual-cavity cabinet design, in which one of the 6 1/2-inch RST-2 bass and bass/mid drivers work into separate enclosures, tuned to different frequencies and impedances. This provides improved power handling and delivers faster, deeper, more dynamic bass and greater transparency through the crucial mid-range. Above that, the gold C-CAM tweeter ensures a smooth, detailed sound all the way up to 43 kHz, exploiting the full potential of the latest wide bandwidth digital formats.” “Amazing at it may seem, a centre speaker may be required to reproduce over 60% of the entire output of a film sound-track. This means that it must deliver the dramatic impact of explosions and sound effects as precisely as it recreates the many tonal subtleties of dialogue. The outstanding dynamic reach and generous power handling of the Gold Signature LCR speaker allow it to master the most dynamic drive conditions with ease and still have something in reserve. Monitor Audio has optimised the design to provide accuracy and control over a wide listening area while preserving the exact tonal signature and balance of the GS series. This means that the GS LCR will integrate perfectly with any of the speakers in the Gold Signature range.” “The GS-FX is a completely new design from Monitor Audio. Its advanced dualmode configuration can be switched automatically by a processor to accommodate a range of surround sound applications. The speaker’s slim-profiled angled baffle design incorporates no fewer than three driver pairs. When used in monopole mode to reproduce side or rear channels, its front-firing 6 1/2-inch RST-2 bass/mid driver and gold C-CAM tweeter come into play, delivering an accurate wide-bandwidth sound-field to complement perfectly a front-channel GS speaker combination. The GS-FX in dipole mode uses two side-firing pairings of of 4-inch C-CAM bass/mid driver and gold C-CAM tweeter combined with the tailored output from front-firing bass/mid driver to provide wonderfully diffuse yet tonally precise surround effects.” The subwoofer provided for review was from the Silver group of speakers: “The RSW-12 active subwoofer provides another stunning dimension to the Silver RS sound. Its 12-inch (300mm) C-CAMTM front-firing driver, powered by a potent 500W (RMS) digital amplifier, will extend the reach…to add the deepest drama to movies and music. The RSW-12’s lowest frequencies are controlled so expertly that even subtle effects are better defined…” There, I couldn’t have said it better myself, though I might have arranged the hyphens and commas a little differently, and cut some of the hyperbole. But all this does show that MA has put a lot of thought into creating coordinated high end HT systems to suit all users equally. And it’s evident too that, depending on the type of home theatre you envision, you can employ multiples of either GS-LCR or GS-FX speakers to provide the desired precise or ambient surround and effect channels in combination. We have quite a complex set of measurements for this excellent upper tier home theatre speaker system, with virtually identical PNS (Pink Noise Sweep) at top, indicating almost perfect dispersion of sound in front of and well to the side of each GS 20, with just the expected (less so in fact) rolloff at the very top of the frequency range. Looking at the axial measurements just below, we see virtual symmetry at 0 and 15 degrees off axis, with just the expected rolloff at 30 degrees above 10 kHz. Bass extension is flat to 70 Hz, with a gentle rolloff, down 5 dB at 50 Hz, and just 7 dB at 30 Hz, very respectable deep bass, and still going at 20 Hz, off about 12 dB. This is a quite compact true full-range loudspeaker, with a very smooth across-the-band response. The GS-LCR matches well, with bass response holding well to 70 Hz (3d curve group down) and smooth upper bass and midrange above, and showing the same general slope and shelf above through the mids and into the treble. Its 30 degree off-axis measurement does show some lack of energy between 1 and 3 kHz, typical of systems in which the woofer/mids flank the tweeter. That’s of course, when it’s on its side, the driver array not showing this horizontal lobing effect when vertical. But the effect here is minor, a couple of dB, and will be in most cases covered up by radiation in the same range by left and right speakers. And now let’s talk about the RSW-12 subwoofer. First, let me note that the relative levels of the measurements are accurately shown with quite interesting unintended results. I started at our standard 85 dB level with the crossover setting at full rotation in what is called EQ1 mode (this latter selectable on top at rear where the overall level control is also located in the Silver medallion section). We see that first measurement just slightly above the the GS 20 axial curves at left. Frankly, it’s not very promising, offering little in the way of deep bass extension, what a subwoofer should be all about, and the next curve down, at half rotation, is no better, both down 9 or 10 dB relative to 100 Hz. After these two runs with the LMS system (both the result of 4 averaged actual measurements, as with all subs to ensure accuracy), I was starting to wonder about this supposedly “high end” sub. However, as I continued, things got more interesting. With the crossover at minimum rotation I got a trace that looked very much like the response of the KEF sub without any adjustment, this RSW-12 curve seen below and to the left of the GS-LCR curves, +/-1 dB from 20 to 100 Hz, exemplary, and comparable to the best subs we’ve used and measured. It seems that Monitor Audio has left a little too much adjustment room in this subwoofer, that is, enough to make it sound bad, or at best inadequate. Hey, who could be happy without any deep bass from a high end sub? High end HT is very much a byword with the Monitor Audio Gold system. This is a very fine and beautiful system in its glossy black, and the sound quality matches very well, the surround imaging exemplary, as expected, and the bass solidity and speed commensurate with this company’s much improved engineering in recent times. It’s about $8000 of HT “Kit” as the Brits say, and worth every farthing. Andrew Marshall Related Reviews:AIG Back Issues: Winter 1992Paradigm Monitor 7 v2 Loudspeaker AIG Back Issues: Winter/Spring 2007 ADAM Classic Series Compact Monitor AIG Back Issues: Fall 2003 One Response to “Monitor Audio Gold Signature Home Theater Speaker System”Comment On this Post |
The CD in Decline A Brief History of the LP Worst Album Sales Week Ever The Devolution of Sound Quality Solar Powered Speaker Array Audio Ideas (Andrew Marshall) Ox Box (Bob Oxley) Hy End (Hy Sarick) Bain's Blog (John Edward Bain)
Recent Comments:
|
February 12th, 2008 at 7:45 pm
Andrew,
Great review! Thanks a lot! I like GS speakers very much.
Would you only please make the graphs a bit more readable? Better in color and with short description about all the measured curves.
BTW, some MA RS/GS f.r. graphs I saw before indicated +14dB tweeter resonance at 19kHz or about. Did you notice it?
THANKS